On Sunday we both ordered the turkey, dressing, and mashed potato dinner. It was so good. The mashed potatoes were perfect and the dressing was better than anything my family has ever been able to come up with at Thanksgiving! It was served with chicken gravy, never my first choice, but the Theo brothers even got that right.
In the past I have tried various soups, even some crazy pepperoni pizza soup, and they have always been good. The stranger they sound, the better they are. We've never tried any of the Italian dishes, I'm always very leery to order Italian at non-Italian places, but the pizza always smells good.
If you're in the area, you're not going to find a better restaurant than The Forum.